Intro

Issue

TROLL model currently compute leaf lifespan with Reich’s allometry (Reich et al. 1991). But we have shown that Reich’s allometry is underestimating leaf lifespan for low LMA species. Moreover simulations estimated unrealistically low aboveground biomass for low LMA species. We assumed Reich’s allometry underestimation of leaf lifespan for low LMA species being the source of unrealistically low aboveground biomass inside TROLL simulations. We decided to find a better allometry with Wright et al. (2004) GLOPNET dataset.

We tested different models starting from complet model Mcomp: \[ {LL_s}_j \sim \mathcal{logN}(log({\mu_s}_j),\,\sigma)\,, ~~s=1,...,S_{=4}~, ~~j=1,...,n_s\]

\[{\mu_s}_j = {\beta_0}*e^{{\beta_1}_s*{LMA_s}_j^{{\beta_3}_s} - {\beta_2}_s*{Nmass_s}_j^{{\beta_4}_s}}\] \[{\beta_i}_s \sim \mathcal{N}({\beta_i},\,\sigma_i)\,^I\] \[(\beta_i, \sigma, \sigma_i) \sim \mathcal{\Gamma}(0.001,\,0.001)\,^{2I+1}\]

LL graph

Figure 1: Leaf mass per area (LMA), leaf nitrogen content (Nmass) and leaflifespan (LL). Leaf mass per area (LMA in \(g.m^{-2}\)), leaf nitrogen content (Nmass, in \(mg.g^-1\)) and leaf lifespan (LL in \(months\)) are taken in GLOPNET dataset from Wright et al. (2004).

M1

Model

\[ LL \sim \mathcal{logN}(\beta_0 + {\beta_1}_s*LMA + {\beta_2}_s*N,\sigma)\,\] Maximum likekihood of 9.0770378 and \(R^2\) of -7.773

Convergence

M2

Model

\[ LL \sim \mathcal{logN}(\beta_0 + LMA^{{\beta_3}_s} + N^{{\beta_4}_s},\sigma)\,\] Maximum likekihood of -1.5236724 and \(R^2\) of -6.694

Convergence

M3

Model

\[ LL \sim \mathcal{logN}(\beta_0 + {\beta_1}_s*LMA^{{\beta_3}_s} + {\beta_2}_s*N^{{\beta_4}_s},\sigma)\,\] Maximum likekihood of 25.0943989 and \(R^2\) of -43.165

Convergence

M4

Model

\[ LL \sim \mathcal{logN}(\beta_0 + {\beta_1}_s*LMA + N,\sigma)\,\] Maximum likekihood of 1.5213978 and \(R^2\) of -3.12

Convergence

M5

Model

\[ LL \sim \mathcal{logN}(\beta_0 + LMA^{{\beta_3}_s} + N^{{\beta_4}_s},\sigma)\,\] Maximum likekihood of -2.0383414 and \(R^2\) of -5.646

Convergence

M6

Model

\[ LL \sim \mathcal{logN}(\beta_0 + {\beta_1}_s*LMA^{{\beta_3}_s} + N^{{\beta_4}_s},\sigma)\,\] Maximum likekihood of 6.3916138 and \(R^2\) of -4.65

Convergence

M7

Model

\[ LL \sim \mathcal{logN}(\beta_0 + {\beta_1}_s*LMA,\sigma)\,\] Maximum likekihood of 4.4543991 and \(R^2\) of -8.681

Convergence

M8

Model

\[ LL \sim \mathcal{logN}(\beta_0 + LMA^{{\beta_3}_s},\sigma)\,\] Maximum likekihood of -6.3152327 and \(R^2\) of -4.844

Convergence

M9

Model

\[ LL \sim \mathcal{logN}(\beta_0 + {\beta_1}_s*LMA^{{\beta_3}_s},\sigma)\,\] Maximum likekihood of 9.5668923 and \(R^2\) of -18.44

Convergence

Results

Results

M1 M2 M3 M4 M5 M6 M7 M8 M9
ML 9.077000 -1.524000 25.09400 1.521000 -2.038000 6.392000 4.454000 -6.315000 9.56700
R2 -7.772557 -6.693773 -43.16481 -3.119532 -5.645636 -4.650274 -8.680647 -4.844123 -18.43983

Figure 3: Model predictions.

References

Reich, P.B., Uhl, C., Walters, M.B. & Ellsworth, D.S. (1991). Leaf lifespan as a determinant of leaf structure and function among 23 amazonian tree species. Oecologia, 86, 16–24.

Wright, I.J., Reich, P.B., Westoby, M., Ackerly, D.D., Baruch, Z., Bongers, F., Cavender-Bares, J., Chapin, T., Cornelissen, J.H.C., Diemer, M. & Others. (2004). The worldwide leaf economics spectrum. Nature, 428, 821–827.